/A Tale of Three Carbonaras

A Tale of Three Carbonaras

Spaghettoni abruzzesi alla carbonara, Roscioli

I’ve been talking about carbonara a lot lately. It has come up in conversation no fewer than six times today with friends, family and clients. I’ve always been a fan of this dish in which pasta is tossed with egg yolk (and sometimes albumen), pecorino cheese, guanciale and black pepper, but 2010 was a record-setting year for my carbonara consumption–and I’m not doing to shabby in 2011, either. After a serious

amount of obsessing research, I’ve found the three carbonara dishes every visitor to Rome should try. If the average visit lasts three nights, that’s more than enough time to taste them and leaves time for other must-eats like pizza by the slice at Pizzarium, gelato at Claudio Torce’, and fried starters at Nonna Betta. Here are the results of my great carbonara quest, in no particular order:

Da Danilo (Via Petrarca 13, Esquilino): a very dry version of carbonara made with spaghetti, pancetta*, egg yolk, and black pepper. The pasta is served in a compact tangle of spaghetti strands and garnished with a crisp piece of pancetta (not guanciale). In the summer, a variation with zucchini and saffron is also served.

Roscioli (Via dei Giubbonari, Campo): This “branded” gourmet version of the Roman classic is made with Verrigni‘s thick spaghetti, guanciale* from Monte Conero, Paolo Parisi eggs, Rimbas malesiano black pepper (recognized by Slow Food), pecorino romano, and pecorino from Moliterno. The guanciale is crispy and cubed, the cheese is pungent, pepper aromatic, and pasta fragrant. The Parisi eggs are the least noticeable (and therefore least necessary) luxury item in this carbonara and could easily be substituted with something less absurd, though they are an essential part of the name-dropping penchant of this heart stopping dish.

L’Arcangelo (Via GG Belli, Prati): Verrigni’s rigatoni are tossed with egg yolk, mature guanciale, and toasted ground black pepper (sometimes this is omitted). The eggs aren’t designer, just those supplied by Fortunato Longino in the Prati Market (box 67) You can find the recipe (in Italian) here. Simple, saucy and silky, the short pasta adds a new dimension to the must eat Roman dish.

Order a bottle of Marco Carpinetti’s Cori Bianco “Capolemole” and you’re good to go.

*mistranslated as bacon on the menu–this is unsmoked cured pork belly; I don’t think Da Danilo doesn’t has an English menu!


  1. Hande March 26, 2011 at 9:37 pm - Reply

    yes, yes! but you are trying to send everyone somewhere else so we still get places at roscioli, right? because it is at giubbonari 21…. btw, does torce still have the place between circo massimo & piramide?

  2. Katie March 27, 2011 at 12:37 am - Reply

    haha im so burnt i put the bakery address. changed to the correct one. as far as i know the shop is still on via aventino. its not torce’s tho. it’s his gelato and someone else owns it.

  3. Alfredo deBonis March 27, 2011 at 2:29 am - Reply

    Hi Kathy, A belated happy birthday. Another place to try a great carbonara is a Birreria on the Via Giordano Bruno across from the school and off Via Andrea Doria. As for the recipe, I prefer using the whole egg. Just the yolk tends to make it paste. But as the ancient Romans use to say “De Gustibus non Disputandum est” Hope to be in Rome this October. Ciao

  4. […] Food Skip to content HomeAboutBookstoreContactPress ← A Tale of Three Carbonaras March 27, 2011 · 2:44 am ↓ Jump to […]

  5. semsa denizsel March 27, 2011 at 11:56 pm - Reply

    I had 2 of them! We need to go back to L’Arcangelo and try that too.

  6. Katie March 28, 2011 at 5:32 pm - Reply

    @Alfredo grazie! i use some egg white too:)

    @semsa sounds like a plan!

  7. […] dishes are among the city’s tastiest: the spaghetti alla Carbonara was also mentioned by this food writer last week as among the best in […]

  8. […] Danilo: Roman food with a hint of modernity. Da Danilo is home to one of my favorite carbonaras in the city. Be sure to specify a table upstairs. Open on Easter Sunday at lunch. Call […]

  9. […] Danilo: Roman food with a hint of modernity. Da Danilo is home to one of my favorite carbonaras in the city. Be sure to specify a table upstairs. Open on Easter Sunday at lunch. (San […]

  10. […] around for the carbonara which is one of the best in […]

Leave A Comment

You are currently not connected to the internet